Viewpoint: The Stopping Power of Hot Nuclear Matter

  • Cristina Manuel, Instituto de Ciencias del Espacio (IEEC/CSIC), Campus of Universidad Autonoma de Barcelona, E-08193 Bellaterra (Barcelona), Spain
Physics 7, 97
LHC experiments show that the quark-gluon plasma stops jets made of light and heavy quarks equally well, offering insights into a state of matter thought to have existed in the early Universe.
Figure 1: (Top) When two high-energy protons collide, the partons that compose them (here only quarks are depicted in green, red, and blue) can hit each other. Some of these partons (pink balls) can fly away and “hadronize,” forming directional jets of energetic hadrons (white balls). (Bottom) Proton-proton collisions can also occur in the early stages of heavy-ion collisions. In this case the produced jets propagate in a dense quark-gluon-plasma (QGP) fireball. Because of momentum conservation, at least two jets are always generated, traveling in opposite directions. Often, one of the two jets is extinguished, or “quenched.”(Top) When two high-energy protons collide, the partons that compose them (here only quarks are depicted in green, red, and blue) can hit each other. Some of these partons (pink balls) can fly away and “hadronize,” forming directional jets of energet... Show more

When a bullet is shot into a dense substance, it is stopped after traversing a characteristic distance. By determining the stopping power of the material and analyzing how the energy of the projectile is transferred to the medium, one can gather important information on the projectile, the medium, and their interactions. Some of the most complex experiments carried out at large particle-accelerator facilities around the world do essentially the same thing: The projectiles are made of jets of hadrons (subatomic particles made of quarks and gluons) and the propagating medium is a small, extremely hot fireball, which is not much larger than the nucleus of a heavy atom and falls apart in less than 10-21 seconds. This fireball, created by colliding heavy ions at high energies, goes through a phase called quark-gluon plasma (QGP) (a state of matter in which quarks and gluons are liberated from the hadrons), while the jets of hadrons are naturally formed in the initial stages of the heavy-ion collisions. The Compact Muon Solenoid (CMS) Collaboration at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) has now studied how jets made up of hadrons containing a specific type of quarks (bottom quarks) are stopped or “quenched” in these peculiar QGP fireballs. The results—similar to those obtained in earlier experiments on jets made of lighter quarks—suggest that, under similar conditions, quenching occurs in the same way for jets of quarks with different masses [1].

Observing how jets made of different particle types are quenched in the QGP might help reveal the fundamental properties of this hard-to-probe state of matter, believed to have existed in the very early Universe mere millionths of a second after the big bang. The Universe was in a QGP phase—so hot that that the protons and neutrons that would later make up atomic nuclei were still melted in their constituents: quarks and gluons. Nowadays, the temperature and density conditions needed to reach the QGP phase of matter can be recreated in terrestrial particle accelerators [such as at CERN and at the RHIC (Relativistic Heavy Ion Collider) accelerator of the Brookhaven National Laboratory] by smashing together heavy ions, like gold or lead, at ultrarelativistic velocities, reaching temperatures several hundreds of thousand times higher than those found at the center of the Sun.

In these experiments, the heavy ions collide and their hundreds of protons and neutrons melt into a QGP fireball, which then expands and cools down. The individual quarks and gluons then recombine to form a different set of hadronic particles, such as protons, neutrons, pions, kaons, etc. The particles in this collision debris fly apart in all directions and are captured by the laboratory’s particle detectors. The collected data can then be used to infer the properties of the QGP fireball formed in the initial stages of the collision.

When two individual protons collide at high energies in vacuum, the partons that compose them (parton is the generic name given to the constituents of the nucleons: quarks and gluons) can hit each other. In some of these collisions, a large amount of energy is transferred to those partons, which fly away with high momentum from the collision axis. Later, the partons “hadronize,” i.e., they form localized, directional sprays of energetic hadrons called jets (see Fig 1, top). These processes are well understood within quantum chromodynamics (QCD), the theory describing strong nuclear interactions.

The same sort of highly energetic proton-proton collisions can be produced in the early stages of heavy-ion collisions, but in this case, the situation is more complex: many jets are produced and propagate in a dense QGP fireball (see Fig 1, bottom). Thus, as in the case of the bullet propagating in a dense medium, the jets can be stopped or almost extinguished, depending on the stopping power of the QGP. Because of momentum conservation, at least two jets are always generated, traveling in opposite directions. But often one of the two jets in the pair is extinguished. This phenomenon, called “jet quenching,” was first observed at RHIC in 2001 [2,3], and later confirmed at the LHC, through experiments exploring higher values of the transverse (relative to the beam axis) jet momentum ( pT).

To describe how hot nuclear matter affects the propagation of jets, physicists measure the so-called nuclear modification factor ( RAA), given by the ratio of the yield of high- pT particles measured in nucleus-nucleus collisions over the same yield in proton-proton collisions (scaled by the appropriate number of equivalent pp collisions). A value of RAA close to 1 indicates that high- pT particles are not affected at all by the hot nuclear matter in the fireball. And this is indeed the value found for particles that do not directly experience strong nuclear interactions, like photons or Z bosons (elementary particles that mediate the weak interaction and are unaffected by the strong force). A value of RAA smaller than 1 is instead found for other hadronic particles, such as pions or kaons, meaning that jets of these particles lose energy through their propagation in the medium. The value of RAA is also affected by the collision geometry [4].

The effectiveness of jet quenching could also be expected to depend on the flavor (or type) and the mass of the propagating partons. RAA had been measured previously for different sets of light hadrons consisting of light-mass quarks (up, down, or strange quarks), yielding values in the 0.2 0.5 range, depending on the values of pT and on the centrality of the collision. Now, the CMS Collaboration has focused on hadrons that contain a heavier bottom ( b) quark, finding, within the same range of transverse momentum pT, similar RAA values. This is surprising, as a b quark is roughly one thousand times heavier than an up quark. This leads the researchers to conclude that jet quenching, in the range of momenta they studied, does not have a strong dependence on the mass of the propagating parton.

How can the stopping power of the QGP fireball be the same for “bullets” with very different masses? Several theoretical models have been proposed to describe the possible energy-loss mechanisms for a parton traversing a QGP, each delivering different predictions for its mass and flavor dependence. Such models depend on the value of the QCD coupling constant (the parameter describing the strength of the nuclear force interaction) [5] and on how the QGP medium is represented.

When these sorts of experiments were planned, it was thought that weakly coupled methods would be enough to describe them. But a 2011 study [6] found that the QGP behaves as an almost perfect liquid, rather than as a gas, pointing to strongly coupled behavior. In contrast, the new result of the CMS Collaboration suggests that a small-coupling-constant model would better explain the weak mass dependence of the observed jet quenching. What all these seemingly contradictory results could imply is that QGP physics is very different for different spatial scales. At the short distances probed by jets, the data indicate that the system is weakly coupled. However, over larger scales on which many-body, collective effects develop, the QGP behaves as strongly coupled. This scale dependence could be naturally explained as a consequence of QCD’s asymptotic freedom (meaning that the strength of the interaction becomes weaker and weaker when considering processes at higher and higher energies).

Experimental results such as these reported by the CMS Collaboration [1] are exceptionally valuable given the demanding physics involved: Describing, from first principles, the many-body processes in the matter produced after heavy-ion collisions is a challenging task because of the complexity of QCD. Thus different approximations and models have to be used, and these hard-to-gather data provide us with a unique opportunity to validate or discard such models. Clearly, more experimental data and theoretical effort are still needed to tackle this complex problem, which, ultimately, is about understanding how matter behaved in the early moments of our Universe.

This research is published in Physical Review Letters.


  1. S. Chatrchyan et al. (CMS Collaboration), “Evidence of b-Jet Quenching in PbPb Collisions at sNN=2.76TeV,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 113, 132301 (2014)
  2. K. Adcox et al. (PHENIX Collaboration), “Suppression of Hadrons with Large Transverse Momentum in Central Au+Au Collisions at sNN=130 GeV,’’ Phys. Rev. Lett. 88, 022301, (2001)
  3. J. Adams et al. (Star Collaboration), “Transverse-Momentum and Collision-Energy Dependence of High-pT Hadron Suppression in Au+Au Collisions at Ultrarelativistic Energies,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 91, 172302 (2003)
  4. Since in a head-on collision the resulting fireball is bigger, the partons’ energy loss is much higher than in a peripheral collision, in which there are fewer initial colliding nucleons and the volume of the fireball is smaller
  5. D. d’Enterria “Jet quenching,” Landolt-Börnstein, New Series, Group I, Vol. 23 (Springer Verlag, Berlin, 2010); arXiv:0902.2011
  6. H. Song, S. A. Bass, U. Heinz, T. Hirano, and C. Shen, “200 A GeV Au+Au collisions serve a nearly perfect quark-gluon liquid,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 106, 192301 (2011); Erratum, 109, 139904 (2012)

About the Author

Image of Cristina Manuel

Cristina Manuel is a tenured researcher of the Spanish Research Council, working at the Instituto de Ciencias del Espacio (IEEC-CSIC) of Barcelona, Spain. She received her Ph.D. in physics from the Universitat de Barcelona, and afterwards she was a research associate at MIT, a CERN fellow, and a Marie Curie Fellow at CERN. She is an expert on QCD under extreme temperature and density conditions and is interested in finding signatures of exotic QCD phases in astrophysical scenarios.

Subject Areas

Nuclear PhysicsParticles and Fields

Related Articles

Synopsis: Neutrino Flashes from Exploding Stars

Synopsis: Neutrino Flashes from Exploding Stars

Calculations indicate that neutrino emission from a supernova could be detected on Earth, possibly revealing how the star explodes. Read More »

Synopsis: Model Tries to Solve Five Physics Problems at Once
Particles and Fields

Synopsis: Model Tries to Solve Five Physics Problems at Once

A minimal extension to the standard model of particle physics involves six new particles. Read More »

Focus: Proton-Neutron Equilibration Takes Just 0.3 Zeptoseconds
Nuclear Physics

Focus: Proton-Neutron Equilibration Takes Just 0.3 Zeptoseconds

The equilibration of nuclei containing a large imbalance of protons and neutrons can occur in 3×10−22 seconds, according to experiments—important information for models of element-creation in supernovae. Read More »

More Articles