Synopsis: Screening and the Coulomb interaction

How screening affects the Coulomb interaction has long been considered a solved problem, but an analysis indicates there is an error in the widely used analytical approach.
Synopsis figure
Illustration: Alan Stonebraker

In the 1960s and 1970s, several papers (see for example Refs. [1–4]) reported the solution to the problem of Coulomb scattering. Starting with a screened Coulomb potential, one could obtain the corresponding screened Coulomb “t matrix.” In the limit of an infinite screening radius, it was stated that the on-shell t matrix, which accounts for observable effects, approaches the physical one except for an infinitely oscillating phase factor that is known analytically. Removing this factor—a process called renormalization—it is possible to obtain the physical Coulomb result from the screened Coulomb potential approximation.

This standard renormalization method for determining the physical t matrix from a screened on-shell t matrix has enjoyed widespread use. However, according to a paper appearing in Physical Review C by Walter Glöckle and Jacek Golak at the Ruhr-Universität Bochum in Germany and Roman Skibiński and Henryk Witała at Jagiellonian University in Kraków, Poland, the accepted renormalization factor is incomplete. The standard analytic renormalization factor, which is generally believed to be valid for any type of screening and is used widely in the literature, is seemingly missing a term that is singular at forward and backward scattering angles.

Glöckle et al. present numerical results to illustrate the error in the standard renormalization approach. The implications of their findings for prior numerical calculations could be significant. – Ben Gibson

[1] V. G. Gorshkov, Sov. Phys. JETP 13, 1037 (2962); 20, 234 (1965).

[2] W. F. Ford, Phys. Rev. 133, B1616 (1964); J. Math. Phys. 7, 626 (9166).

[3] J. R. Taylor, Nuovo Cimento B 23, 313 (1974).

[4] M. D. Semon and J. R. Taylor, Nuovo Cimento A 26, 48 (1975).


Announcements

More Announcements »

Subject Areas

Statistical Physics

Next Synopsis

Nonlinear Dynamics

Solitons in an ionic crystal

Read More »

Related Articles

Viewpoint: An Equation of State for Active Matter
Statistical Physics

Viewpoint: An Equation of State for Active Matter

An equation of state for a gas of self-propelled spheres is a step towards a thermodynamic description of “active” matter, such as bird flocks and tissue. Read More »

Focus: Liquid Helium Brewed Locally
Industrial Physics

Focus: Liquid Helium Brewed Locally

A new device for recycling the helium coolant in an MRI scanner or similar machine uses elevated pressure to dramatically increase the rate at which helium is liquefied. Read More »

Viewpoint: History is Written by the Survivors
Biological Physics

Viewpoint: History is Written by the Survivors

A new approach is able to quantify the environmental effects on an evolving organism by analyzing just a small number of surviving individuals. Read More »

More Articles