Avoiding Instabilities in Hydrogen-Spiked Flames

Physics 17, 79
Experiments show the effects on combustion of adding hydrogen to natural gas—a fuel mixture that could reduce carbon emissions from power plants.
Gassing up with hydrogen. Adding hydrogen to natural gas could make power-plant emissions less polluting. New experiments explore the onset of instabilities in flames fueled by a mixture of hydrogen and natural gas.

The greenhouse-gas emissions of gas-fired power plants can be reduced if their fuel includes some hydrogen, but such mixtures raise concerns over flame instabilities that could damage plant equipment. New experiments have explored the onset of so-called thermoacoustic instabilities in flames fed with natural-gas fuel spiked with hydrogen [1]. The measurements reveal various ways in which these instabilities can propagate in a commonly used ring-shaped combustor. Engineers can use the information as they develop plans for next-generation power plants and jet engines.

Thermoacoustic instabilities can arise in a combustor—the chamber where pressurized fuel is ignited in a power-plant gas turbine or a jet engine. The instabilities originate from heat fluctuations in the flame. “You can hear these fluctuations in the fluttering of a gas-burner flame,” says Nicholas Worth from the Norwegian University of Science and Technology. The fluctuations create pressure oscillations (sound waves) that can reflect off surrounding equipment and travel back to the flame, causing a modulation in the inflow of fuel that affects the original heat fluctuations. This feedback creates standing pressure waves at various frequencies within the combustor. In some cases, the amplitude of one of these standing waves can grow to a dangerous level.

Manufacturers carefully design their combustors to avoid thermoacoustic instabilities. But those designs are typically specific to a certain type of fuel, which in the case of power plants is natural gas. Recently, there has been interest in reducing carbon dioxide production by adding clean-burning hydrogen to natural gas. The presence of hydrogen will, however, alter the flame properties. Worth and his colleagues have investigated hydrogen’s effect in a lab-based combustor that includes pressure sensors and transparent windows for imaging the flames.

B. Ahn/Norwegian University of Science and Technology
Flaming up. Experiments with a mixture of hydrogen and natural gas reveal conditions that lead to flame instabilities. The top panel shows a longitudinal-wave instability that propagates in the vertical direction; the bottom panel shows an azimuthal-wave instability that goes around the ring-shaped combustor in the horizontal direction.

Researchers have previously studied thermoacoustic instabilities in lab-based combustors that typically had only one flame. The combustor in Worth’s lab has a ring shape with 12 separate flame inputs. This annular design, which is similar to those used in commercial combustors, allows pressure oscillations both around the ring (azimuthally) and in the direction of the gas flow (longitudinally). “The configuration we have includes a lot of the relevant physics in real engines,” Worth says.

In the experiments, the fuel was a mixture of hydrogen and natural gas, with about 60–70% hydrogen by volume. Compared to pure natural gas, the researchers observed that the flame size was—as expected—smaller when hydrogen was added. They also saw differences in the pressure response as the amount of fuel injected into the combustor was ramped up. Initially, the amplitude of longitudinal waves grew, signaling the onset of an instability. But as the amount of fuel increased, the instability switched to azimuthal waves. This switching behavior was not observed in trials using pure natural gas.

Worth says the observations could be useful for combustor manufacturers. Current combustors are considered safe for small amounts of hydrogen mixed with natural gas, but less is known about the effects of larger amounts of hydrogen. The new data from Worth and his colleagues could guide engineers developing numerical simulations of combustor dynamics. The researchers are also working on extending their experiments to liquid fuels, as there is an interest in using hydrogen as a replacement for jet fuel to reduce the carbon footprint of aviation.

“Hydrogen-blended gas turbines are attracting much attention owing to their reduced emissions,” says mechanical engineer Minwoo Lee from Hanbat National University in South Korea. But he says that thermoacoustic instabilities are hampering this development. “The results of the researchers’ study provide a profound understanding of the complex dynamics of hydrogen-blended hydrocarbon combustion, opening up possibilities for predicting and evading detrimental instabilities,” Lee says.

–Michael Schirber

Michael Schirber is a Corresponding Editor for Physics Magazine based in Lyon, France.


  1. B. Ahn et al., “Longitudinal and azimuthal thermoacoustic modes in a pressurized annular combustor with bluff-body-stabilized methane-hydrogen flames,” Phys. Rev. Fluids 9, 053907 (2024).

Subject Areas

Fluid DynamicsEnergy Research

Related Articles

Ocean Currents Resolved on Regional Length Scales
Computational Physics

Ocean Currents Resolved on Regional Length Scales

Using a detailed simulation, researchers reveal how climate change will affect the regional dynamics of the conveyor-belt-like circulation of water through the Atlantic Ocean. Read More »

A Slight Curvature Gives Pebbles an Impacting Edge
Fluid Dynamics

A Slight Curvature Gives Pebbles an Impacting Edge

Pebbles that are slightly curved—rather than completely flat—exert the highest impact forces when dropped onto a watery surface. Read More »

Predictions for Small-Scale Turbulence
Fluid Dynamics

Predictions for Small-Scale Turbulence

A statistical tool tests the long-held assumption that small-scale turbulence is isotropic. Read More »

More Articles