Synopsis: Ranking scientists

An analysis of the citation network leads to an alternative way to quantitatively assess the impact of a scientist’s work.
Synopsis figure
Illustration: F. Radicchi et al., Phys. Rev. E (2009)

Most metrics of a scientist’s impact in a field, like the h-index, rely primarily on the number of times his or her papers have been cited, and can miss the more subtle ways that knowledge and credit for this research spread among scientists. Now, in a paper appearing in Physical Review E, Filippo Radicchi and Santo Fortunato at the Institute for Scientific Interchange in Torino, Italy, and Benjamin Markines and Alessandro Vespignani at Indiana University in the US are instead proposing a way to rank scientists that reflects the diffusion of scientific credit in time. Their method, based on an algorithm similar to Google’s PageRank, takes into account several nontrivial effects such as the fact that being cited by an important author has more influence than being cited by one who is less well known.

By analyzing a set of about 400,000 papers published between 1893 and 2006 in the Physical Review, Radicchi et al. establish a ranking according to their “Science Author Rank Algorithm.” They show that the probability of winning a physics prize is consistently higher for authors who have top positions, according to their algorithm, than for other popular metrics. Moreover, the top positions in their ranking are not necessarily held by those scientists who have garnered the greatest number of citations.

Assessing scientists and their merit has, nowadays, become a crucial task for many policy makers. Radicchi et al.’s paper reminds us that a scientist’s merit and scientific impact cannot always be encoded in a single number, but results from a complex process of interactions between the members of the scientific community. In this respect, this paper is a beautiful first step towards a credible alternative quantitative ranking of scientists’ work. – Marc Barthelemy


Features

More Features »

Announcements

More Announcements »

Subject Areas

Interdisciplinary Physics

Previous Synopsis

Next Synopsis

Plasma Physics

A skein of plasma

Read More »

Related Articles

Viewpoint: Acoustic Experiments without Borders
Interdisciplinary Physics

Viewpoint: Acoustic Experiments without Borders

A new approach to laboratory acoustic experiments could remove unwanted effects caused by the reflections of acoustic waves from the boundaries of the experimental setup. Read More »

Synopsis: The Geometry of Arctic Ponds
Geophysics

Synopsis: The Geometry of Arctic Ponds

A geometric model of meltwater ponds may help predict how the polar ice caps might evolve under future climate changes. Read More »

Synopsis: Financial Brownian Motion
Complex Systems

Synopsis: Financial Brownian Motion

Using data on the activity of individual financial traders, researchers have devised a microscopic financial model that can explain macroscopic market trends. Read More »

More Articles