Synopsis: Sandy Scaling Law

Theory, simulations, and experiments suggest that the performance of vehicle wheels of arbitrary shape rolling over sand can be predicted using scaled-down models.
Synopsis figure
J. Slonaker et al., Phys. Rev. E (2017)

Getting trapped in a sand pit is a nightmare scenario for space rovers like NASA’s Curiosity or, closer to home, for anyone who drives in the desert. But calculating exactly how a vehicle’s wheels interact with and move across billions of individual sand grains isn’t trivial. Now Ken Kamrin and colleagues at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, have derived a set of scaling laws that relate the size, mass, and spin rate of a wheel, as well as the environment’s gravity, to its ability to move across a sand bed. The researchers suggest that these simple relations could be employed to accurately predict the performance of tanks, trucks, or space rovers in sandy environments using scaled-down vehicle models in the lab.

The team considered a wheel of arbitrary shape and mass rolling over a sandy surface with a fixed rotational rate. Treating the sand as one continuous medium rather than a collection of individual grains, they calculated how much the sand pushes back—the resistive force—as the wheel pushes down. This allowed them to derive scaling equations for how much power is needed to drive a wheel over the sand and for the resulting translational velocity with which the wheel moved. Experiments with differently sized cylindrical and lug wheels, which have four arms and appear to “walk” across the sand, digging little pockets of sand as they go, as well as simulations of bar-shaped wheels, which move by flipping end-over-end, showed good agreement with the theory as the wheels’ loading, spin rate, and ambient gravity were varied—the data all collapsed onto the same predicted lines.

This research is published in Physical Review E.

–Katherine Wright

Katherine Wright is a Contributing Editor for Physics.


More Features »


More Announcements »

Subject Areas

Soft Matter

Previous Synopsis

Next Synopsis

Related Articles

Viewpoint: Porous Materials Exhibit Granular-Like Stress Chains
Materials Science

Viewpoint: Porous Materials Exhibit Granular-Like Stress Chains

Simulations of porous materials exhibit internal stress patterns like those in granular materials, despite the fact that these two systems are practically “negative images” of each other. Read More »

Focus: Bacteria Form Waveguides
Biological Physics

Focus: Bacteria Form Waveguides

A laser beam sent through a suspension of marine bacteria pulls the organisms into the beam, which focuses the light. Read More »

Synopsis: Friction Means Life or Death for Ants
Soft Matter

Synopsis: Friction Means Life or Death for Ants

Experiments show that the mass of an object determines whether it slides down a sandy slope, which may explain why insect predators called antlions can trap ants in sand pits. Read More »

More Articles