Arts & Culture

Repackaging a Mathematically Odd Bottle

Physics 14, 126
Stepan Paul creates mathematically correct sculptures to help teach complex math concepts.
S. Paul/North Carolina State University
Stepan Paul hopes that his latest sculpture, which depicts a so-called Klein bottle, will help viewers visualize mathematical properties of the object that are hard to see in other renderings.

Creating art was not originally a life goal of Stepan Paul, a mathematician at North Carolina State University. Rather, he says, he stumbled into making sculptures after he got involved in a teaching project that visualizes math structures using a 3D printer. That initial foray hooked Paul, who has since hand-molded hyperbolic structures from paper and 3D-printed paraboloids from plastic. His latest piece—a “Klein bottle” that he folded from transparency film—was on display at the recent Bridges Conference, a meeting that brings together those interested in both math and art (see Physics Abounds at Conference on Math and Art).

The Klein bottle is a topological oddity, which is traditionally depicted in 3D as a “jug” whose “spout” transitions into a handle. The jug has a hole that you can pour liquid into but getting it back out is tricky (and messy). Klein bottles are like Möbius strips in that they are surfaces that, if traveled upon, can take the traveler back to their point of origin while turning them upside down—leave a Klein-bottle jug’s spout head up and you’ll return head down. Some Klein bottles, unlike spheres or cubes, can also be flattened with no finagling: It’s impossible to flatten a sphere or a cube without tearing the object or deforming its surface, while some Klein bottles can be squashed into 2D completely intact.

Yang MingQi/stock.adobe.com
In the most common depiction of a Klein bottle, the object resembles a jug.

These weird properties can make it hard to visualize a Klein bottle. Even with a Klein-bottle jug in hand, the twists and turns of its surface can be hard to follow, as some of them occur inside the jug or handle. The jug also can’t be flattened, Paul says, an issue he wanted to rectify.

For his Klein bottle, Paul used an origami technique known as curved crease origami, where a structure is generated from folds along curved creases, rather than straight ones. He took a transparency film, which had been printed on one side with a roughly square blue lattice and on the other with a matching white lattice. He then fashioned the plastic into a structure that resembles a triangularly folded tube whose inside and outside surfaces switch places at each vertex, as well as in the middle of one side of the structure, where the ends of the transparency are held together with red tape.

Paul says that he used the two colors to help people follow the flips of the surface. But he notes that the lattices can trick the eye a little. Viewed head on, it can be hard to believe that the creases are actually creases, he says. “You might think I cheated and taped the pieces of transparency together.” But that visual impression, he says, makes it easier to imagine the object being flattened.

S. Paul/ North Carolina State University
The folds of Paul’s sculpture can trick the viewer into thinking that the object is flat, rather than 3D.

Paul created this Klein bottle while working from home because of the COVID-19 pandemic. As such, the sculpture has yet to be featured in one of his classes. When he does return to “in-office” work, Paul says that he plans to put the sculpture on a shelf in his office, where he hopes it will captivate passing students and spark a conversation between him and them. “I’m always interested in attracting people into math who might otherwise not have thought about studying it,” he says. “Art has great outreach potential.”

–Katherine Wright

Katherine Wright is the Deputy Editor of Physics.


Recent Articles

Turning a Quantum Computer into a Time Crystal
Quantum Information

Turning a Quantum Computer into a Time Crystal

Google’s Sycamore quantum processor can simulate an elusive quantum system called a discrete time crystal. Read More »

Toward Skin-Like Electronics

Toward Skin-Like Electronics

A technique that allows researchers to fabricate 42,000 elastic transistors per square centimeter takes them a step closer to creating electronic devices that look and behave like skin. Read More »

A Way to Experimentally Test String Theory’s “Fuzzball” Prediction
Gravitation

A Way to Experimentally Test String Theory’s “Fuzzball” Prediction

Simulations reveal the gravitational-wave signal of string theory’s “fuzzy” black holes, a signature that researchers could potentially measure. Read More »

More Articles