Viewpoint: Do alpha particles cluster inside heavy nuclei?

Physics 3, 8
New excited states have been observed in 212Po that are associated with a configuration in which an alpha particle is combined with a doubly-magic 208Pb core.
Figure 1: Partial level scheme for 212Po. Excited states are labeled by their excitation energy and are given in keV. Parity assignments enclosed in parentheses are consistent with the data, but an opposite parity assignment, while unlikely, cannot be ruled out. States associated with the ground state (positive parity) and the 3 octupole-vibrational (negative parity) configurations are given in blue and are well understood within the framework of the shell model. States with odd spin and positive parity (far left) and even spin negative parity (far right) that cannot be explained by the shell model are given in red. Arrows connecting these states with the shell model states indicate the observed electric-dipole transitions (E1) whose lifetimes have been measured by Astier et al. to be <2 picoseconds. These transitions are labeled by their energy in keV. The red states as well as their decay properties are explained by a cluster model which assumes they are associated with a 208Pb+α configuration.Partial level scheme for 212Po. Excited states are labeled by their excitation energy and are given in keV. Parity assignments enclosed in parentheses are consistent with the data, but an opposite parity assignment, while unlikely, cannot be ruled ou... Show more

In the early part of the 20th century as physicists became aware of the existence of the nucleus, they speculated that the nucleus might be composed of α particles [1]. This picture of the nucleus was eventually supplanted by the shell model, which considers nuclei to consist of neutrons and protons held together by an average potential generated by nucleon-nucleon interactions. This model is highly successful in describing both ground-state properties and excited states in nuclei under the assumption that the building blocks are individual protons and neutrons. However, in the 1960s, excited states in nuclei that comprise equal numbers of protons and neutrons, (e.g., 12C and 16O) were identified that could not be described by the shell model, and it was suggested by Ikeda and others that these states could be associated with configurations composed of α particles [2].

Alpha clustering in light nuclei is now well established [3]. These states are found at the decay thresholds in nuclei with neutron number equal to the atomic number ( N=Z) and having total mass A<30. In many instances, they are associated with chains of α particles forming elongated, exotic shapes. For instance, the so-called Hoyle state in 12C, whose existence is essential for the nucleosynthesis of carbon via the triple- α process, is an example of an α-cluster state. Because these configurations cannot be described by the shell model, so-called cluster models have been developed to characterize these states. In heavier nuclei, cluster states have not been observed. Nevertheless, the concept of α particles existing inside the nucleus even in heavier systems is employed in order to describe α decay, which is a common decay mode for heavy nuclei. For example, the α-decay width for 212Po is an order of magnitude larger than predicted by the shell model. As a consequence, the ground-state properties of 212Po can only be reproduced by assuming both shell model and clusters states exist in 212Po. On the other hand, the shell model can describe reasonably well the known excited states in 212Po without invoking a cluster model. Thus it has been unclear whether states in 212Po exist that can be associated with a cluster configuration.

Now, in a paper in Physical Review Letters, Alain Astier and colleagues in France, Bulgaria, and Romania report a study identifying excited levels in 212Po whose properties can be understood with a model that associates these states with a 208Pb+α configuration [4]. In order to search for such cluster states, the authors performed an experiment using an α-transfer reaction where an 85- MeV 18O beam, supplied by the Vivitron tandem accelerator of IRES (Strasbourg), was incident on a 100mg/cm2 208Pb foil. States in 212Po were populated when an α particle was transferred from the 18O beam to the 208Pb target. The motivation for using this reaction was that if states associated with a 208Pb+α configuration exist in 212Po, they would be preferentially populated using an α−transfer reaction. Once the transfer takes place, the 212Po nucleus is left in an excited state and decays back to the ground state by the emission of γ rays. For this experiment, the emitted γ rays were detected by the Euroball IV γ-ray detector array [5], which consisted for this experiment of 71 Compton-suppressed high-purity germanium (HPGe) detectors. HPGe detectors are used because of their superior energy resolution when measuring energies of individual γ rays ( 2- keV FWHM energy resolution for 1- MeVγ rays). The large number of detectors allowed for the collection in excess of 109 events where three or more γ rays were detected in coincidence. These multicoincidence data allow for the construction of nuclear level schemes, which are mappings of excited levels in nuclei (see Fig. 1 ).

From the analysis of the data, 35 previously unknown excited states have been identified in 212Po. Information obtained from γ-ray angular distributions, as well as transition selection rules, allows for the assignment of spin and parity to some of the newly observed levels. In addition, if γ rays are emitted by the nucleus while it is slowing down in the target, these transitions will have a non-Gaussian peak shape associated with them. By analyzing the line shape of a γ-ray transition as a function of detector angle relative to the velocity direction of the recoiling nucleus, the lifetime of the state emitting the γ ray can be deduced. For the reaction used in this experiment, γ rays emitted from states with lifetimes on the order of 1 picosecond will exhibit line shapes.

Figure 1 shows a partial level scheme for 212Po. Known states associated with the ground state configuration (positive parity, even spin) and states coupled to an octupole vibrational excitation (negative parity, odd spin) are shown in blue. These states can be well understood within the framework of the shell model. In addition, a new set of states which have even-spin, negative parity (Fig. 1, right side) and a set of states with odd-spin, positive parity (Fig. 1, left side) have been identified. The former set of levels decay to members of the ground-state band, while the latter members decay to levels comprising the octupole vibrational band. These new states cannot be explained by the shell model. The connecting transitions between these new sets of states and the shell model states (represented as arrows in Fig. 1 ) have an electric-dipole multipolarity ( E1), and, based on the lifetime measurements, they are relatively fast ( τ<2 picoseconds).

The observed E1 transitions are several orders of magnitude faster than one would expect between shell model states. Such “enhanced” E1 transitions are rare in nuclei and are usually associated with nuclei having an asymmetric mass distribution. For example, electric-dipole transitions with similar decay strengths as measured in 212Po have been observed in some actinide nuclei, and these states have been associated with octupole deformed shapes [6]. As pointed out by Astier and collaborators, the 208Pb+α configuration also has an asymmetric mass distribution. Using a model where they assumed the α particle moves in the average field of the nucleus, they were able to show that the sequence of states assigned to the cluster configuration in Fig. 1 is what is expected when an α particle vibrates against the 208Pb core, however, the ordering of the states does not agree with expectations due to mixing with the shell model states.

While more theoretical work is needed to better quantify the observed spectrum of excited states, one could also imagine similar states existing in, for example, 216Rn, which can be thought of as consisting of two α particles outside a 208Pb core. In this instance, the α particles could behave coherently resulting in a similar set of states observed in 212Po or independently resulting in a more complex ordering of states associated with the cluster configuration.


  1. H. A. Bethe and R. F. Bacher, Rev. Mod. Phys. 8, 82 (1936)
  2. K. Ikeda, N. Takigawa, and H. Horiuchi, Prog. Theor, Phys. Suppl. Extra Number, 464 (1968)
  3. W. von Oertzen, M. Freer, and Y. Kanada-En’yo, Phys. Rep. 432, 43 (2006)
  4. A. Astier, P. Petkov, M-G. Porquet, D. S. Delion, and P. Schuck, Phys. Rev. Lett. 104, 042701 (2010)
  5. J. Simpson, Z. Phys. A 358, 139 (1997)
  6. I. Ahmad and P. Butler, Ann. Rev. Nucl. Part. Sci. 43, 71 (1993)

About the Author

Image of Michael P. Carpenter

Michael Carpenter received his Ph.D. in 1989 from the University of Tennessee for his work on the study of high-spin states in 184Pt and 183Au. Upon receiving his graduate degree, he spent one year at the Neils Bohr Institute as a post-doctoral fellow (1989). This was followed by a postdoctoral appointment at Argonne National Laboratory (1990–1991) where he was later promoted to the scientific staff in the Physics Division (1992–present). Currently, he is the scientific project manager of the Gammasphere detector array. The focus of his research activity is the study of the structure of nuclei under the influence of high angular momentum.

Subject Areas

Nuclear Physics

Related Articles

Synopsis: Neutrons On-Demand from Laser Fusion
Nuclear Physics

Synopsis: Neutrons On-Demand from Laser Fusion

A new laser-driven fusion method could lead to a robust and efficient way to generate neutrons for use in materials science, geology, and other fields. Read More »

Focus: Proton-Neutron Equilibration Takes Just 0.3 Zeptoseconds
Nuclear Physics

Focus: Proton-Neutron Equilibration Takes Just 0.3 Zeptoseconds

The equilibration of nuclei containing a large imbalance of protons and neutrons can occur in 3×10−22 seconds, according to experiments—important information for models of element-creation in supernovae. Read More »

Synopsis: Starting Fluid for Laser Fusion
Energy Research

Synopsis: Starting Fluid for Laser Fusion

A laser-based fusion experiment demonstrates that liquid fuel capsules could rectify problems encountered with ice-based fuel capsules. Read More »

More Articles