Viewpoint: Hybrid Atom-Optomechanics

  • Albert Schliesser, Ecole Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne (EPFL), CH-1007- Lausanne, Switzerland and Max Planck Institute für Quantenoptik, Garching, D-85748, Germany
  • Tobias J. Kippenberg, Ecole Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne (EPFL), CH-1007- Lausanne, Switzerland and Max Planck Institute für Quantenoptik, Garching, D-85748, Germany
Physics 4, 97
Coupling a silicon nitride membrane resonator with a gas of ultracold atoms offers a novel approach to controlling mechanical systems at the quantum level.
Adapted from S. Camerer et al. [3]
Figure 1: A hybrid atom-nanomechanical interface used by Camerer et al. [3]. The mechanical oscillator (a thin silicon nitride membrane) is coupled to a cold atomic sample (right) by an optical field. Importantly, the coupling via the standing wave laser fields allows the researchers to entirely separate the physical locations, which may prove highly versatile in future, cryogenic experiments.A hybrid atom-nanomechanical interface used by Camerer et al. [3]. The mechanical oscillator (a thin silicon nitride membrane) is coupled to a cold atomic sample (right) by an optical field. Importantly, the coupling via the standing wave laser field... Show more

Researchers have used laser fields for decades to achieve extraordinary control over the quantum states of atoms, molecules, and ions. Condensed-matter physicists have recently made fast progress in achieving a similar level of control over nano- and micromechanical oscillators, i.e., lithographically engineered structures. Among the opportunities that drive this effort is the possibility of detecting and controlling these devices at the quantum level. Reaching this quantum regime makes it possible to prepare the mechanical oscillator in pure quantum states and observe how it evolves under interaction with the environment, potentially revealing yet unobserved decoherence mechanisms. From an applied perspective, such studies may also enable researchers to create sensors with improved sensitivity.

What makes mechanical systems attractive in this context is the large mechanical quality factor of micro- and nanomechanical systems (that is, their ability to store energy in resonant states for very long periods). One especially interesting case is silicon nitride [1]: membranes made of this material exhibit dissipation mechanisms that are surprisingly reduced and the subject of much research [2]. Building upon this earlier work with silicon nitride, Stephan Camerer from Ludwig Maximilians University, Germany, and colleagues report in Physical Review Letters [3] their progress in achieving atomic-mechanical coupling.

One method to achieve such control, which has recently been widely explored, consists of coupling the mechanical motion parametrically to an optical or microwave cavity mode, a technique first envisioned by Braginsky [4]. Indeed, optomechanical coupling allows substantial control of the mechanical oscillator state, including quantum-limited readout of its position and the preparation of the oscillator with very low residual thermal motion. The result is a mechanical oscillator that spends a significant fraction of its time in the quantum ground state. Despite the impressive progress made in cavity optomechanics [5,6] these schemes are approaching but not quite at the level of control that can be attained in atomic physics. In a different experiment, O’Connell et al. used a microwave field to mediate the coupling of a superconducting qubit to a high-frequency piezoelectric mechanical oscillator [7], enabling the intriguing observation of the swapping of quantum states between the qubit and the oscillator.

More generally, coupling the mechanical device to a fully controlled quantum system appears to be a promising route. Among the many proposals for such hybrid quantum systems, experiments that use ultracold atoms as the quantum “handle” on the mechanics are particularly attractive. Theorists have put forward a number of proposals of how atomic systems—such as a trapped ion [8–10], atom [11], Bose-Einstein condensate (BEC) [12], or atomic ensemble [13–15]—could be coupled to a mechanical device.

In the group of Theodor Hänsch, Philipp Treutlein and his colleagues at Ludwig Maximilians University have pioneered the practical implementation of such proposals. Recently, they have demonstrated the coupling of a BEC to a micromechanical cantilever via surface forces [16]. On their handy “atom-chips,” they managed to probe the motion of a micromechanical cantilever with a BEC approached to its surface. The oscillations of the cantilever caused a clearly discernable loss of atoms when it resonated with modes in the BEC; however, the backaction of the atoms on the mechanical motion could not be observed. The backaction in this case is the force that the atoms exert via the light field on the mechanical oscillator; it is precisely this backaction that mediates the mutual coupling between the two systems.

In the new work reported by Camerer et al. [3], this group accomplishes the feat of seeing the backaction (see Fig. 1) by elegantly implementing atomic-mechanical coupling via shared optical forces. The two coupled systems are an ensemble of about a million optically trapped atoms and a nanomechanical oscillator, consisting of a 50-nanometer, thin silicon nitride membrane mounted like a drumhead on a 0.5-millimeter silicon frame. These oscillators have dramatically different masses, with the membrane’s mass exceeding the mass of all atoms by about 8 orders of magnitude. It is a surprisingly simple trick that allows coupling these two oscillators: The optical standing wave that provides the atoms’ lattice trapping potential is created by (partially) reflecting a laser beam from the membrane instead of a fixed mirror. From an experimentalist’s point of view, this is an intriguing arrangement [13], as the light used for coupling can be shuttled over a long optical path to connect the two subsystems, which can consequently be held in completely different environments.

But how does it work? In the first place, the standing wave, in whose antinodes the atoms are held, moves along with the membrane (Fig. 1). Therefore, if the membrane is moving, a force is exerted on the atoms proportional to the membrane’s displacement. At the same time, atomic motion does act back on the membrane: By its very nature, the optical trap forces each atom back to its equilibrium position if it moves out of the trap center. Importantly, however, the origin of this force is a redistribution of photons between the running-wave components that form the standing wave. As a consequence, the optical power propagating towards the membrane is modulated, and so is the radiation-pressure force on the membrane. Indeed, if optical losses and the finite transmission of the membrane are neglected, the forces experienced by the displaced atom and the membrane are exactly equal in magnitude, following the action-reaction principle.

The mutual coupling of membrane and atomic motion resulting from these forces becomes particularly clear if only the atomic center-of-mass mode—in which all atoms move in unison in (ideally) identical trapping potentials—is considered. The atomic motion and the membrane’s displacement then form a pair of optically coupled harmonic oscillators, with the coupling forces enhanced by the number N of atoms in the lattice.

In their study, the authors could detect this coupling by investigating the damping induced upon the membrane by the atoms. As the atoms are cooled by another laser field (and additionally undergo dephasing), their motion is damped at a much higher rate ( 130 kilohertz) than the oscillations of the membrane ( 0.2 hertz). By tuning the two oscillators into resonance (choosing the appropriate optical power), an increase of the membrane damping was clearly observed, following the expected linear dependence on the atom number N. A more elaborate model, taking into account the finite temperature of the atoms and the different trapping frequencies of atoms at different locations, could also fully reproduce the damping measured when the trapping frequency is tuned away from this degeneracy resonance.

In a second set of experiments, the researchers switched off the laser cooling of the atoms, and the mechanical mode of the membrane was excited by a piezoelectric transducer. The resulting heating of the atoms—with excitations of the center-of-mass mode quickly redistributed among their motional degrees of freedom—was measured. Again, resonant heating was observed when the “oscillators” were degenerate.

In future work, larger coupling would allow the full quantum control made possible by the atoms, which can be prepared in nonclassical states. Stronger coupling may be realized by using more atoms, placing the membrane in a cavity, or by using a different coupling arrangement, which overcomes the scaling with the square root of the mass ratio [11]. Moreover, the mechanical decoherence, i.e., the rate at which one quantum is lost to the environment, can be reduced. This rate, given by the energy damping multiplied by the mean phonon occupancy, can be decreased for silicon nitride by cryogenic precooling. The remote coupling demonstrated by Camerer et al. could be an enabling step in this context. It may then become possible to fully exploit the quantum coherent coupling between an atomic cloud and a micromechanical oscillator, and allow quantum control of solid-state systems.


  1. J. D. Thompson et al., Nature 452, 72 (2008)
  2. I. Wilson-Rae et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 106, 047205 (2011)
  3. S. Camerer, M. Korppi, A. Jöckel, D. Hunger, T. W. Hänsch, and P. Treutlein, Phys. Rev. Lett. 107, 223001 (2011)
  4. V. B. Braginsky and A. B. Manukin, Measurement of Weak Forces in Physics Experiments, edited by David H. Douglass (University of Chicago Press, 1977)[Amazon][WorldCat]
  5. T. J. Kippenberg and K. J. Vahala, Science 321, 1172 (2008)
  6. F. Marquardt and S. Girvin, Physics 2, 40 (2009)
  7. A. D. O’Connell et al., Nature 464, 697 (2010)
  8. D. Wineland et al., J. Res. Natl. Inst. Stan. Technol. 103, 259 (1998)
  9. L. Tian and P. Zoller, Phys. Rev. Lett. 93, 266403 (2004)
  10. W. K. Hensinger et al., Phys. Rev. A 72, 041405 (2005)
  11. K. Hammerer et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 103, 063005 (2009)
  12. P. Treutlein, D. Hunger, S. Camerer, T. Hänsch, and J. Reichel, Phys. Rev. Lett. 99, 140403 (2007)
  13. K. Hammerer et al., Phys. Rev. A 82, 021803 (2010)
  14. C. Genes, D. Vitali, and P. Tombesi, Phys. Rev. A 77, 050307 (2008)
  15. D. Meiser and P. Meystre, Phys. Rev. A 73, 033417 (2006)
  16. D. Hunger et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 104, 143002 (2010)

About the Authors

Image of Albert Schliesser

Albert Schliesser is a post-doctoral fellow at the Ecole Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne in the Laboratory of Photonics and Quantum Measurement and a guest at the Laser Spectroscopy division of the Max-Planck-Institute of Quantum Optics. He obtained his Ph.D. from Ludwig Maximilians University and is a recipient of the Otto-Hahn medal and the EPS thesis prize. His research interests include optical micoresonators, cavity optomechanics, frequency comb generation and spectroscopy, as well as near-field optical techniques.

Image of Tobias J. Kippenberg

Tobias J. Kippenberg is Associate Professor of Physics and Electrical Engineering at EPFL and leads the Laboratory of Photonics and Quantum Measurement. He obtained his B.A. at the RWTH Aachen, and M.A. and Ph.D. at the California Institute of Technology (Caltech in Pasadena, US). From 2005 to 2009 he led an Independent Research Group at the MPI of Quantum Optics. He is an alumnus of the Studienstiftung des Deutschen Volkes and winner of the 8th EU Contest for Young Scientists (1996) for his invention of an infrared-microwave radiation ice condition sensor for cars. For his invention of chip-scale frequency combs, he is co-recipient of the Helmholtz Price for Metrology (2009). Moreover, he is recipient of the EFTF Young Investigator Award (2010) and the EPS Fresnel Prize (2009).

Read PDF

Subject Areas

Atomic and Molecular PhysicsOptics

Related Articles

Synopsis: A Lens to Focus Spins
Quantum Information

Synopsis: A Lens to Focus Spins

A quantum bit stored in the spin excitation of an atomic cloud could be “focused” onto the quantum state of a single atom. Read More »

Synopsis: The Softness of an Atom’s Touch
Atomic and Molecular Physics

Synopsis: The Softness of an Atom’s Touch

Two spectroscopic probes are combined to measure the “softness” of collisions between cold atoms. Read More »

Focus: Vortices of Light on the Cheap

Focus: Vortices of Light on the Cheap

A simple laser setup has spontaneously produced nonuniform polarization patterns called vector vortices. Read More »

More Articles