Synopsis

Eve Fools Alice and Bob

Physics 4, s156
Experiments with classical light sources show that tests of Bell’s inequalities can be manipulated to yield counterfeit quantum answers.

In the 1960s, physicists agonizing over the apparent paradoxes of quantum mechanics posed a question: Could quantum strangeness be explained by a deeper theory with correlations augmented by local hidden variables? In the midst of the debate, John Bell published a set of bounds on the possible correlations of entangled systems. If the correlations obeyed Bell’s inequalities, then they were classical; violations indicated quantum behavior. Since then, it has been tempting to assume that Bell’s inequalities are the gold standard for distinguishing quantum character from classical counterfeits. But what if there are loopholes in the fine print? And what about the security of quantum cryptographic techniques that depend on Bell tests of quantum correlations?

Writing in Physical Review Letters, Ilja Gerhardt, from the National University of Singapore, and colleagues report experiments showing that an eavesdropper, Eve, can use such loopholes to make classical correlations appear quantum to Alice and Bob, two parties in a supposedly private communication. The result reveals that there are indeed loopholes that must be closed before signing off on the results of a Bell test or before Alice and Bob could completely trust their quantum cryptographic system.

The authors’ experiments used a standard setup for testing Bell inequalities by means of single-photon detectors, crucial tools in quantum information systems. However, their light source was entirely classical, consisting of strong, carefully tailored pulses of light that overwhelm and manipulate the detection process to yield apparently single-photon responses of the desired character. The results show that Bell’s inequalities are a good test of quantum behavior only if all the loopholes in their measurement are closed. It may be essential, the authors conclude, to verify that events are really causally separated and to ensure that the single-photon detectors rarely fail to detect a photon. – David Voss


Subject Areas

Quantum Information

Related Articles

Toward Autonomous Quantum Communication
Quantum Information

Toward Autonomous Quantum Communication

A machine-learning algorithm previously used to solve navigation problems can devise efficient ways to transmit quantum information. Read More »

Protecting Molecular Qubits from Noise
Atomic and Molecular Physics

Protecting Molecular Qubits from Noise

A new proposal for how to encode quantum information in the rotational states of individual molecules could protect these qubits from losing information as a result of noise. Read More »

Fewer Lasers Achieve Higher Fidelity Logic Gate
Atomic and Molecular Physics

Fewer Lasers Achieve Higher Fidelity Logic Gate

Researchers halve the number of lasers needed to implement a quantum logic gate between two different atomic species, a feat that could help to create a scalable quantum computer. Read More »

More Articles