Synopsis

Freeze frame

• Physics 4, s22
Images reveal some of the factors that determine the shapes of icicles.
Credit: A. Chen and S. W. Morris, Phys. Rev. E (2011)

At a glance, the icicles dangling from the edge of a house on a cold day all look pretty much like long, inverted cones. Look more closely though, and it is possible to see they are not perfectly conical, but more subtly curved, like a carrot.

Despite the many parameters involved, theorists have predicted that icicles, as well as other natural features like stalactites, should all converge to the same shape as they grow. In a paper appearing in Physical Review E, Antony Chen and Stephen Morris at the University of Toronto, Canada, describe an experimental setup that allows them to image icicles as they grow under controlled conditions, and test these predictions. They mounted a camera through a slot in the side of a refrigerator, within which icicles formed as water dripped from a nozzle and onto a rotating wooden support. Rotating the support helps even out the effects of drafts and temperature gradients.

Chen and Morris imaged 93 icicles, documenting the shapes of fully grown icicles formed from both frozen tap and distilled water. For the most part, the shape of icicles follows a simple theoretical prediction: the diameter varies as the distance from the tip to the 3/4th power (i.e., it is sublinear). Where this relation fails, one culprit is the purity of the water. Tap water has more impurities and a lower surface tension, which Chen and Morris find makes icicles more susceptible to bending, twisting, and forming ripples along their sides. – Jessica Thomas


Subject Areas

Interdisciplinary Physics

Related Articles

A Little Noise Helps a Soft Valve Close
Biological Physics

A Little Noise Helps a Soft Valve Close

A simplified model of the heart’s mitral valve shows that flow fluctuations can cause a soft valve to close at about one-tenth the pressure required under steady flow. Read More »

Chess Reveals Differences Between Human and AI Strategies
Interdisciplinary Physics

Chess Reveals Differences Between Human and AI Strategies

Chess grandmasters move toward a less complex game faster than AI players, suggesting different approaches for balancing short- and long-term prospects. Read More »

Whale Calls Reveal an Unexpected Wave Effect
Interdisciplinary Physics

Whale Calls Reveal an Unexpected Wave Effect

A theory inspired by whale tracking suggests that interference could make the peak of a light-wave packet appear to travel faster than light—without transmitting information superluminally. Read More »

More Articles