Synopsis: Electrons or phonons–which are the bigger drag?

The sources of friction between two surfaces can be difficult to pin down.
Synopsis figure
Illustration: M. Pierno et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. (2010)

As two materials are dragged across one another, do conduction electrons at the surface make a significant contribution to friction?

An elegant approach to this deceptively simple question is to measure the friction between a metal and a monolayer of a simple gas, at temperatures above and below the metal’s superconducting transition. This turns the dissipative contribution from electrons “on” and “off,” respectively. Experiments of this kind between nitrogen gas and lead revealed that friction drops by a factor of 2 below the lead superconducting transition, indicating electrons and phonons make roughly equal contributions to friction.

But, as Matteo Pierno, Giampaolo Mistura, and colleagues at Università di Padova and Università di Genova in Italy argue in Physical Review Letters, their friction experiments contradict these earlier experiments, leaving the various sources of friction an open question.

Pierno et al. coated the faces of a quartz disk with smooth layers of lead. Like the quartz crystal in a watch, the quartz disk is piezoelectric and oscillates in a shearing mode when excited by an ac voltage at its resonant frequency. When neon gas condenses on the lead surface, friction between the lead and neon layer dampen the oscillation.

However, Pierno et al. don’t measure a further change in the oscillation amplitude when they toggle the temperature back and forth across the superconducting transition. Within the sensitivity of their setup, they conclude that surface conduction electrons don’t contribute significantly to friction–a “null result” that suggests the interpretation of these measurements may be more complicated than previously thought. – Jessica Thomas


Announcements

More Announcements »

Subject Areas

Nanophysics

Previous Synopsis

Next Synopsis

Related Articles

Synopsis: Coulomb Drag in a Double Dot
Nanophysics

Synopsis: Coulomb Drag in a Double Dot

Electric current passing through a quantum dot can generate current in a nearby dot through a coordinated tunneling mechanism. Read More »

Synopsis: Taking Pictures with Single Ions
Atomic and Molecular Physics

Synopsis: Taking Pictures with Single Ions

A new ion microscope with nanometer-scale resolution builds up images using single ions emitted one at a time from an ion trap. Read More »

Synopsis: Measuring Spin One Atom at a Time
Magnetism

Synopsis: Measuring Spin One Atom at a Time

Electron microscopy experiments have measured the spin state of individual metal atoms on a graphene layer, characterizing their potential for information storage applications.   Read More »

More Articles