Synopsis: Closing Quantum Loopholes

New experiments strengthen confidence in the quantum weirdness of photons
Synopsis figure
B. G. Christensen et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. (2013)

The oddness of quantum mechanics came to the fore in an epic face-off between Einstein and Bohr in the 1930s. On one side, Einstein said that quantum mechanics discards accepted notions of localism (a measurement couldn’t be influenced by a remote experiment) and realism (outcomes of measurements only depend on the thing being measured, not on the measurer). On the other side, Bohr said that’s right, and you’d better get used to it. Writing in Physical Review Letters, Bradley Christensen at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign and colleagues report an experiment that solves one of the major experimental limitations that have denied a definitive win for quantum mechanics.

In the 1960s, John Bell put the debate on a quantitative footing by publishing mathematical inequalities that, if violated, would conclusively rule out any classical theory, local and realistic, as an alternative to quantum mechanics and thus explain observations like entanglement. Many experiments have shown that quantum systems violate Bell’s inequalities, but they are all hampered by at least one of two loopholes. One, the locality loophole, might allow some kind of information to travel from one particle to another. The second is the detection loophole: if the measurement uses a low-efficiency detector, then you might not be sampling all the entangled photons properly.

A recent paper by another group claiming to have closed the detection loophole is disputed by Christensen et al., who have carried out new measurements with a high-efficiency source of entangled photons and high-efficiency detectors. This eliminates assumptions about properly sampling the entangled photons and, the authors say, firmly closes the door on the detection loophole. And it’s not just of academic interest: Bell tests are currently used to verify the security of proposed quantum communications systems, so ensuring their reliability is important. – David Voss


Announcements

More Announcements »

Subject Areas

Quantum InformationQuantum Physics

Previous Synopsis

Materials Science

Strength Training

Read More »

Next Synopsis

Particles and Fields

The Weaker Side of the Proton

Read More »

Related Articles

Viewpoint: Photon Qubit is Made of Two Colors
Optics

Viewpoint: Photon Qubit is Made of Two Colors

Single particles of light can be prepared in a quantum superposition of two different colors, an achievement that could prove useful for quantum information processing. Read More »

Synopsis: Ten Photons in a Tangle
Quantum Information

Synopsis: Ten Photons in a Tangle

An entangled polarization state of ten photons sets a new record for multiphoton entanglement. Read More »

Synopsis: Quantum States Made with a Pluck
Quantum Information

Synopsis: Quantum States Made with a Pluck

A proposed method of generating phonon states for quantum applications uses a single electron trapped in a suspended carbon nanotube. Read More »

More Articles