Synopsis

Dark Energy Solution for Hubble Tension

Physics 12, s65
A discrepancy between measurements of the cosmic expansion rate might be resolved by adding an extra form of dark energy.
R. Williams/STScI, Hubble Deep Field Team, NASA, ESA

The rate at which the Universe expands, described by the Hubble constant, has long been a difficult quantity to nail down. The two current strategies for determining the Hubble constant are in conflict, and this tension only seems to get worse after each data release. A new theory suggests that the solution could be to add an extra type of dark energy that would have briefly sped up the Universe a long time ago before galaxies appeared.

The Hubble constant can be found “locally” by measuring the speed at which an object (usually a supernova) is moving away from us and dividing by its distance. Another way to estimate the Hubble constant involves extrapolation of data on the early Universe from the cosmic microwave background (CMB). While the two techniques produce similar estimates, the values are separated by a statistically significant 4 sigma.

In deriving the CMB estimate, researchers have assumed a “standard” cosmological model, in which the density of dark energy is constant through time. To resolve the Hubble tension, Marc Kamionkowski of Johns Hopkins University, Maryland, and colleagues imagined a second contribution to the dark energy coming from a so-called scalar field that has a time-varying energy density. Focusing on types of scalar field potentials, the team determined parameters of these potentials that could give just enough acceleration in the early Universe to bring the CMB estimate of the Hubble constant in line with the local measurement. The researchers predicted that the brief acceleration from this scalar field could produce subtle, but detectable, signatures in the CMB that future surveys might observe.

This research is published in Physical Review Letters.

–Michael Schirber

Michael Schirber is a Corresponding Editor for Physics based in Lyon, France.


Subject Areas

Cosmology

Related Articles

A Quantum Signature for the Cosmos
Cosmology

A Quantum Signature for the Cosmos

Certain galaxy patterns might encode whether the Universe’s primordial density fluctuations were quantum or classical in nature. Read More »

Defect or No Defect: It’s a Toss Up
Cosmology

Defect or No Defect: It’s a Toss Up

A theoretical study of phase transitions reveals new universal nonequilibrium features in the statistics of topological defects. Read More »

Neutrinos Might Rescue Hubble
Particles and Fields

Neutrinos Might Rescue Hubble

A proposed interaction between neutrinos might explain a discrepancy in measurements of the Universe’s expansion rate.   Read More »

More Articles