Active Particles Crystalize

Physics 14, 70
Under the right conditions, self-propelled particles collectively transition from a state of liquid-gas coexistence to one where the particles can crystalize, according to simulations.
A. K. Omar et al. [1]
Self-propelled particles whose directions of motion vary continuously and randomly start in a state of liquid-gas coexistence (green, signifying more disorder) but eventually crystallize (purple, signifying more order).

Collections of small particles can imitate atoms by forming the equivalents of solids, liquids, and gases, following the rules of thermodynamics. However, those rules don’t apply to many systems in the natural world because they are not in equilibrium. Of special interest are systems, such as motile bacteria, that consume energy to power the movement of individual particles, often leading to self-organizing behavior. Now Phillip Geissler, of the University of California, Berkeley, and his colleagues, have used computer simulations to map out the full phase diagram of perhaps the simplest model of self-propelled particles and have found a surprise: a well-known state of these particles—in which regions of liquid and gas coexist—is not completely stable but eventually crystallizes into a solid if conditions are right [1].

The team studied active Brownian particles (ABPs), which are spheres whose propulsion is steady but whose direction varies continuously and randomly. They looked at the behavior of the particles when varying two parameters: the strength of the propulsion and the density of particles. The resulting 2D phase diagram included a large region of liquid-gas coexistence known from previous work as motility-induced phase separation (MIPS).

In equilibrium systems, a liquid-gas coexistence phase (the equivalent of the MIPS state) can crystallize if conditions shift, but it hasn’t been clear whether a solid phase exists near the MIPS state in the phase diagram for nonequilibrium systems. Geissler and his colleagues found that nearly all of the MIPS region of the phase diagram was metastable—not stable for long times—and that, in fact, the particles in this state eventually transition to a coexistence of solid and liquid or solid and gas. Since a preference for solid-gas coexistence is already known for most equilibrium systems, the new observations suggest that the behavior of both types of particles might ultimately be explained with some kind of unified theory, according to Berkeley team member Ahmad Omar.

A. K. Omar et al., [1]
Spheres unfazed. Wait long enough, and the self-propelled spheres in the simulation above (see video) will switch from a liquid-gas coexistence phase to a solid-liquid coexistence phase. This image shows a close-up of a solid-liquid interface.

–David Ehrenstein

David Ehrenstein is a Senior Editor for Physics.


  1. A. K. Omar et al., “Phase diagram of active Brownian spheres: Crystallization and the metastability of motility-induced phase separation,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 126, 188002 (2021).

Subject Areas

Soft MatterCondensed Matter Physics

Related Articles

Hydrophobic Ice More Common than Thought
Condensed Matter Physics

Hydrophobic Ice More Common than Thought

Researchers have observed the formation of 2D ice on gold surfaces that were thought to be too hydrophilic and too rough to support this type of ice. Read More »

Semiconductors in the Spotlight
Materials Science

Semiconductors in the Spotlight

A new model suggests that lattice defects are responsible for the way some semiconductors become harder under illumination. Read More »

Depletion-Force Measurements Get Active
Complex Systems

Depletion-Force Measurements Get Active

Measurements of the attractive force experienced by a passive particle in a bath of active ones and of the microstructure of that system, raise the tantalizing possibility of simple and generic quantitative descriptions of the organization of objects within active and living systems. Read More »

More Articles