Balding Black Holes Lose Their Magnetic Hair

Physics 14, s92
First-principles plasma simulations show that black holes can’t keep their magnetic fields.
A. Bransgrove et al. [1]

According to the physicist John Wheeler, “black holes have no hair”—they can be described entirely by their mass, charge, and spin. However, some researchers have proposed that a classical black hole surrounded by a plasma could retain “hair” in the form of a magnetic field. Ashley Bransgrove, at Columbia University, and his colleagues now show that such a black hole does satisfy the no-hair theorem after all [1]. The result could be tested by x-ray and infrared observations of supermassive black holes, like the one at the center of our Galaxy.

A black hole may be born with a magnetic field, or it may acquire one by swallowing magnetized material. The no-hair theorem says that in such cases, the magnetic field on the event horizon of an isolated black hole should be quickly radiated away, returning the black hole to a “bald” state. But astrophysical black holes don’t exist in isolation. Rather, they are surrounded by plasma that prevents the magnetic field from sliding off the event horizon. What does this mean for the no-hair theorem?

To find out, Bransgrove and his colleagues simulated a magnetic field around a black hole in the presence of collisionless and collisional plasmas. They found that the magnetic field lines break, reconnect, and form plasma-filled magnetic loops that either escape into space or fall into the black hole. The faster the reconnection rate, the quicker the magnetic field decays and the sooner the no-hair theorem is satisfied.

In strong magnetic fields, reconnection produces high-energy x rays. This means that, as well as keeping black holes hair-free, the process could explain observations of x-ray flares and hotspots near supermassive black holes.

–Rachel Berkowitz

Rachel Berkowitz is a Corresponding Editor for Physics based in Vancouver, Canada.


  1. A. Bransgrove et al., “Magnetic hair and reconnection in black hole magnetospheres,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 127, 055101 (2021).

Subject Areas

AstrophysicsPlasma Physics

Related Articles

Mineral Candidates for Planet Interiors

Mineral Candidates for Planet Interiors

Computer simulations uncover new high-pressure minerals that may explain the origin of Earth’s water and of Uranus’ and Neptune’s magnetic fields. Read More »

Quasisymmetric Stellarators

Quasisymmetric Stellarators

Magnetic-field configurations that improve confinement of fusion plasmas in stellarators can be achieved more precisely than previously thought, according to a numerical study. Read More »

Tightening the Net on Two Kinds of Dark Matter

Tightening the Net on Two Kinds of Dark Matter

New dark matter results strengthen constraints on axions and WIMPs. Read More »

More Articles