Shock Waves Emanate from Dying Black Holes

Physics 15, s35
New black hole simulations that incorporate quantum gravity indicate that when a black hole dies, it produces a gravitational shock wave that radiates information, a finding that could solve the information paradox.
Event Horizon Telescope Collaboration

Perhaps the most enigmatic objects in the Universe, black holes embody many unsolved paradoxes. One of their biggest mysteries is the “information paradox,” which emerges from the clashing predictions of quantum mechanics and general relativity. This paradox, which states that information both should and should not disappear when it enters a black hole, may arise because of the breakdown of Einstein’s theory at the black hole’s center. Now, Viqar Husain and colleagues at the University of New Brunswick, Canada, find that they can resolve the paradox by incorporating quantum gravity effects into their simulations, which indicate that when a black hole dies, the information it swallowed during its life is released back into the Universe through a gravitational shock wave [1].

The team considers a model black hole that forms when a large amount of “dust”—simplified matter that doesn’t exert any pressure—collapses under gravity. Tracking the dust particles throughout the black hole’s life allows the team to visualize how the dust moves inside a black hole and how it eventually leaves. They also incorporate quantum gravity into the model by assuming that at the microscopic level, space and time are discrete, coming in quantum “lumps.”

Analyzing the results of their simulations, the team uncovers three surprising findings: First, they see that matter “bounces” inside a black hole, moving both toward and away from the hole’s central point. Second, dying black holes emit a gravitational shock wave that should be detectable by a distant observer. Third, black holes have much shorter lives than previous theories predict. Husain says that the root of both findings is the removal by quantum gravity of a point of infinite density that Einstein’s theory predicts exists at a black hole’s center.

–Katherine Wright

Katherine Wright is the Deputy Editor of Physics Magazine.


  1. V. Husain et al., “Quantum gravity of dust collapse: Shock waves from black holes,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 128, 121301 (2022).

Subject Areas

GravitationParticles and Fields

Related Articles

Neutrino Mystery Endures
Particles and Fields

Neutrino Mystery Endures

New neutrino-oscillation data show no sign of an anomalous signal seen in previous studies, but the analyses can’t yet fully rule out its presence. Read More »

Ionizing Black Hole “Atoms”

Ionizing Black Hole “Atoms”

Distinctive features of gravitational-wave signals from black hole mergers could reveal the existence of long-sought ultralight bosons. Read More »

Revisiting a Cosmological Conundrum

Revisiting a Cosmological Conundrum

A discrepancy between different measurements of the Hubble constant could be removed by the existence of an exotic form of dark matter. Read More »

More Articles