Pore Collapse Leads to Universal Banded Patterns

Physics 15, s73
A model attributes the propagating bands that appear in a compressed porous medium to structural changes alone.
Adapted from L. Blatny et al. [1]

Porous media such as snow, sand, cereals—even bones—develop strikingly similar banded patterns when they’re squeezed. Those bands form when localized deformation zones propagate throughout the material. Understanding what triggers the universal and “material-agnostic” emergence of the bands is a common goal in disciplines including avalanche research, petroleum extraction, structural engineering, geophysics, and agriculture. Now, describing the phenomenon using a model based entirely on a collapsing-pore mechanism, Lars Blatny and his colleagues at the Swiss Federal Institute of Technology, Lausanne, and the University of Sydney, Australia, identify a common origin for these patterns. The result could lead to comprehensive continuum-mechanics models of porous media.

Blatny and his colleagues simulated a vertical 2D slice of an elastoplastic structure that was squeezed from above and below. The structure was perforated with regularly spaced square holes that composed 25% to 75% of its total area. By varying the solid area fraction and the structure’s elasticity and yield strength, the researchers examined how different porous structures deform when compressed at a constant speed. They identified six classes of compaction patterns and found that they could describe these classes entirely by two numbers that characterize the material’s properties and the speed at which the structure was compressed.

L. Blatny et al. [1]
Video showing the six classes of collapse simulated by Lars Blatny and his colleagues.

Although each of these classes has been identified by previous models, those models have relied on empirical hardening or rate laws that are material specific. Blatny’s model captures all the classes within a single framework.

–Rachel Berkowitz

Rachel Berkowitz is a Corresponding Editor for Physics based in Vancouver, Canada.


  1. L. Blatny et al., “Microstructural origin of propagating compaction patterns in porous media,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 128, 228002 (2022).

Subject Areas

Fluid DynamicsSoft Matter

Related Articles

Complex Dance of Light-Seeking Algae in Light Gradients
Fluid Dynamics

Complex Dance of Light-Seeking Algae in Light Gradients

A population of photosynthetic algae has been shown to exhibit a highly nonlinear response to light, forming dynamic structures in light-intensity gradients. Read More »

Small Molecules Twirl Freely in a Helium Droplet

Small Molecules Twirl Freely in a Helium Droplet

A laser nudges deuterium molecules into friction-free motion within a superfluid. Read More »

Looking Inside the Superfluid Helium-3 Universe
Fluid Dynamics

Looking Inside the Superfluid Helium-3 Universe

A camera that can capture the internal structure of superfluid helium-3 will improve our understanding of the turbulent motion of quantum fluids. Read More »

More Articles