Solution for Atomic Clock Puzzle

Physics 16, s160
The resolution of a major discrepancy between theory and experiment for strontium atomic clocks could help improve the precision of these timekeepers.

Strontium atomic clocks have important applications, ranging from tests of general relativity to searches for possible variations in fundamental constants. But the precision of these clocks has been limited by an enduring inconsistency between predictions of their properties and corresponding observations. This disparity has now been rectified by two independent research teams [1, 2]. The results could facilitate the use of strontium timekeepers in the space-based detection of gravitational waves, for example.

In the most precise strontium atomic clocks, a lattice of intersecting laser beams, all with the same “magic” wavelength, traps strontium atoms in certain locations. The interaction between the trapped atoms and the lattice’s electromagnetic field induces a shift in the energies of the atomic energy levels used for timekeeping. The size of this shift depends on two properties of the atoms, known as their magnetic-dipole and electric-quadrupole polarizabilities. But until now, the predicted values of these polarizabilities have conflicted with those measured in experiments.

The two teams resolve this discrepancy by considering previously ignored contributions to the polarizabilities from so-called negative-energy states of the atoms, which are predicted by quantum field theory. These contributions greatly impact the atoms’ magnetic-dipole polarizability but not their electric-quadrupole polarizability. Sergey Porsev at the University of Delaware and his colleagues explain this feature mathematically [1]; Li-Yan Tang and colleagues at the Chinese Academy of Science calculate the contributions both for strontium atomic clocks and for magnesium, calcium, and cadmium ones [2]. The teams’ findings emphasize the need to consider negative-energy states when performing high-precision studies of the interactions between light and matter.

–Ryan Wilkinson

Ryan Wilkinson is a Corresponding Editor for Physics Magazine based in Durham, UK.


  1. S. G. Porsev et al., “Contribution of negative-energy states to multipolar polarizabilities of the Sr optical lattice clock,” Phys. Rev. A 108, L051102 (2023).
  2. F.-F. Wu et al., “Contribution of negative-energy states to the E2-M1 polarizability of optical clocks,” Phys. Rev. A 108, L051101 (2023).

Subject Areas

Atomic and Molecular PhysicsOptics

Related Articles

Seeing Collisions in Cold Molecular Clouds
Atomic and Molecular Physics

Seeing Collisions in Cold Molecular Clouds

Dense ensembles of laser-cooled molecules allow the observation of molecular collisions—a result that could lead to applications of cold molecular gases in quantum simulation and fundamental physics tests. Read More »

Probing Liquid Water’s Structure with Attosecond X-Ray Pulses
Condensed Matter Physics

Probing Liquid Water’s Structure with Attosecond X-Ray Pulses

Using an ultrafast technique, researchers shed light on how the hydrogen-bonded structure of water is reflected in its x-ray spectrum. Read More »

Stiffening a Spring Made of Light

Stiffening a Spring Made of Light

Adding a nonlinear crystal to an optical spring can change the spring’s stiffness, a finding that could allow the use of such devices as gravitational-wave detectors. Read More »

More Articles