Synopsis

No Need for Fractional Particles

Physics 18, s25
The scattering of a charged particle off a magnetic monopole does not imply the existence of fractional particle numbers, theorists say.
Geek3/Wikimedia Commons/CC-BY-SA-4.0

At first glance, the scattering of a massless, charged, fermionic particle off a single magnetic monopole might seem a simple phenomenon to model. Yet when two theorists independently tackled that problem in 1982, they came to the same puzzling conclusion: In the framework of conventional field theory, the scattering resulted in fractional numbers of particles, called semitons [1]. Now Vazha Loladze of Oxford University and Takemichi Okui of Florida State University have taken a fresh look at the puzzle [2]. According to their calculations, the solutions that were understood to imply semitons in fact embody the free propagation of the fermion.

Loladze and Okui’s starting point was a 1984 theory that reduced the dimensions of the problem to a spatial one and a temporal one and that treated the magnetic monopole as a stationary “rotor” with a single internal degree of freedom whose state changed over time [3]. Despite its simplicity, the 1984 model preserved—and clarified—the complicated physics. It also retained semitons. Loladze and Okui modified this model by exciting the rotor and the particle in a way that accounted for the particle’s speed of approach and the rotor’s time-varying state. Doing so removed the semitons but left the rest of the 1982 and 1984 theories intact.

The scattering—and consequent splitting into semitons—of a proton’s quarks off a magnetic monopole has been proposed as a route for proton decay, which shows up unavoidably in certain grand unified field theories. No one has observed a proton decay, which implies that magnetic monopoles are rare. But if magnetic monopoles are no longer implicated in this process, they could be more abundant.

–Charles Day

Charles Day is a Senior Editor for Physics Magazine.

References

  1. V.A. Rubakov, “Adler-Bell-Jackiw anomaly and fermion-number breaking in the presence of a magnetic monopole,” Nucl. Phys. B 203, 311 (1982); C. G. Callan, “Disappearing dyons,” Phys. Rev. D 25, 2141 (1982).
  2. V. Loladze and T. Okui, “Monopole-fermion scattering and the solution to the semiton–unitarity puzzle,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 134, 051602 (2025).
  3. J. Polchinski, “Monopole catalysis: The fermion-rotor system,” Nucl. Phys. B 242, 345 (1984).

Subject Areas

Particles and Fields

Related Articles

Lensing Candidates Stand Out in Euclid Mission’s First Data Release
Astrophysics

Lensing Candidates Stand Out in Euclid Mission’s First Data Release

The Euclid satellite released its first trove of galaxy data based on seven days of deep-field observations in three sky areas. Read More »

LHCb Delivers a Key Piece in the CP-Violation Puzzle
Particles and Fields

LHCb Delivers a Key Piece in the CP-Violation Puzzle

A symmetry violation has been observed in a particle-decay process that—together with five related decays—could shed light on the matter–antimatter imbalance in the Universe. Read More »

New Measurements of a Charmed Baryon
Particles and Fields

New Measurements of a Charmed Baryon

Researchers at the Large Hadron Collider have measured the spin parity of a charm-quark-hosting particle, offering a new test of theoretical models. Read More »

More Articles