Focus: The Physics of Teaching Physics

Phys. Rev. Focus 8, 12
A new model claims that teaching a class is like trying to magnetize a chunk of iron.
Figure caption
©2001 Photodisc, Inc.
Degaussing gossip. A model for classroom learning represents students as atoms that become magnetically aligned when they have all learned the subject. Chitchat is just one source of “social noise” that could frustrate this ferromagnetic behavior.

While most teachers and students were relaxing, a team of physicists spent their summer vacation modeling the physics of learning. They represented the interactions between students and teachers with a set of equations similar to those that describe magnetism in materials like iron. The results, which appear in the 10 September print issue of PRL, are consistent with data on student learning, but can equations convey the complexities of the classroom? Some educational specialists remain unconvinced.

To simulate the classroom environment, Clelia Bordogna and Ezequiel Albano of the Institute of Theoretical and Applied Physical Chemistry in La Plata, Argentina, used a so-called Ising model similar to those that describe magnetism in materials. According to the model, a classroom behaves a lot like a piece of iron: Individual students play the role of atoms, and their knowledge of a subject is similar the atoms’ magnetic orientations. The teacher behaves like an external magnetic field trying to align the student’s knowledge into the “right” direction (understanding the curriculum). But like the atoms in a chunk of iron, the students have other influences: Each student could influence her neighbor’s orientation, and social entropy, such as talking, passing notes, or obscure explanations, could cause the students to become disoriented.

The team’s model made several predictions that agree with data gathered in actual classrooms around the country. For example, when low-achieving and high-achieving students were interspersed in groups, they found that the low-achievers caught on more quickly. They also found that when students influenced each other through group work, they learned the material more thoroughly than when they simply listened to the teacher lecture.

But some educational specialists express skepticism of the study. “Classroom learning shouldn’t be boiled down into a mathematical formula,” said one educational researcher, adding that this kind of work could actually hurt the field by detracting from research on curriculum and teaching principles.

David Byrne, a sociologist who also studies chaos and complexity at the University of Durham in England, believes that trying to model education creates two problems. First, social interactions in the classroom often lack clear boundaries, which can make them difficult to model. Second, human behavior varies significantly, not only among individuals, but among classrooms and regions as well. Such variation, he believes, can throw off even the most general statistical models. Still, Byrne was pleased to see physicists trying to tackle the problem. “Simulations are always interesting–in the social sciences you can’t say much more than that,” he says. But twenty-five years ago, he adds, what would people have said about modeling of biology, economics, and ecology? All of which are commonplace today.

–Geoff Brumfiel


Subject Areas

Complex Systems

Related Articles

Viewpoint: Language Boundaries Driven by Surface Tension
Interdisciplinary Physics

Viewpoint: Language Boundaries Driven by Surface Tension

A new model of language evolution assumes that changes in the spatial boundaries between dialects are controlled by a surface tension effect. Read More »

Synopsis: Pinpointing Ebbs and Flows of Commuter Traffic
Interdisciplinary Physics

Synopsis: Pinpointing Ebbs and Flows of Commuter Traffic

Vulnerabilities in a city’s public transport system are identified through a network analysis that accounts for the number of passengers and vehicles at any given time. Read More »

Synopsis: Straying from the Norm in Pedestrian Movements
Complex Systems

Synopsis: Straying from the Norm in Pedestrian Movements

Experiments tracking people as they walk down a corridor reveal universal behaviors that, if incorporated into models, could ensure safe flow in large crowds. Read More »

More Articles