Synopsis: Superconductivity Model Misses Its Target

Researchers have added dopant atoms to a quantum spin liquid in an effort to make it superconduct, but the material upended theory by remaining an insulator.
Synopsis figure
Zachary Kelly/Johns Hopkins University

High-temperature superconductivity may arise from a disordered spin state, as found in so-called quantum spin liquids. To test this theory, an experimental group doped a quantum spin liquid, called herbertsmithite, and measured changes in its electronic properties. Unexpectedly, the doped samples showed no hints of superconductivity; they didn’t even register as normal conductors. Theorists now have their work cut out explaining why the predictions were off.

The mystery of high-temperature superconductivity is that the traditional mechanism—a phonon-based coupling between electron pairs—does not apply. Among the different models proposed, one involves quantum spin liquids, which are solid crystals whose geometry prevents a simple up-down (antiferromagnetic) pairing of neighboring spins. As a result of this “geometric frustration,” the spins fluctuate (like a liquid) between different pairings. Theorists suggested that adding electrons or holes—through doping—to a spin liquid would allow some of these fluctuating spin pairs to move, and this would lead to superconductivity.

To check this, Tyrel McQueen and colleagues at Johns Hopkins University in Maryland used herbertsmithite, ZnCu3(OH)6Cl2, a quantum spin liquid with a hexagonal crystal structure called a kagome lattice. Previous attempts to dope herbertsmithite (through substitution of elements) have distorted the lattice, thereby canceling the geometric frustration that the spin liquid relies upon. The team started with normal herbertsmithite crystals and inserted lithium atoms—at varying concentration—between the kagome lattice layers. X-ray diffraction measurements verified that the main crystal structure was still in place. However, resistance measurements showed that the material remained insulating, even with the electrons donated by lithium. This contradicts theory, which predicted that doped spin liquids would exhibit multiple phases, most notably a metallic phase and a superconducting phase.

This research is published in Physical Review X.

–Michael Schirber

Michael Schirber is a Corresponding Editor for Physics based in Lyon, France.


More Features »


More Announcements »

Subject Areas


Previous Synopsis

Next Synopsis

Quantum Information

Scaling-Up with a Quantum Socket

Read More »

Related Articles

Viewpoint: Cuprate Superconductors May Be Conventional After All
Condensed Matter Physics

Viewpoint: Cuprate Superconductors May Be Conventional After All

Experiments on a copper-based high-temperature superconductor uncover the existence of vortex states—a hallmark of conventional superconductivity. Read More »

Viewpoint: Order on Command
Condensed Matter Physics

Viewpoint: Order on Command

A current of electrons with aligned spins can be used to modify magnetic order and superconductivity in an iron-based superconductor. Read More »

Synopsis: Photons Couple Like Cooper Pairs

Synopsis: Photons Couple Like Cooper Pairs

A pairing of photons—similar to the pairing of electrons in superconductors—can occur when light scatters in a transparent medium.   Read More »

More Articles