Synopsis

You Don’t Cite Me Anymore

Physics 4, s180
A study of the American Physical Society journals shows that the way in which papers lose relevance over time has a strong influence on the citation statistics.
M. Medo et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. (2011)

Simple models of citation statistics assume that highly cited papers have a better chance of being cited in new papers. However, this preference does not last very long, as evidenced in a new study in Physical Review Letters that examines data from American Physical Society (APS) journals. The authors show that citation models perform better when they account for the way the relevance of a paper decays with time.

As scientists well know, not all papers get cited equally. An often-cited work typically attracts more citations, reflecting the economic maxim of “the rich get richer.” This so-called preferential attachment should yield a smooth power-law distribution in the number of citations to each paper, but literature studies reveal a greater complexity, in part because papers age. Classic treatises from Einstein or Hawking, for example, are no longer cited as they once were. The same is true for other growing networks like the internet, where old web pages attract fewer and fewer links.

Matúš Medo and his colleagues from the University of Fribourg in Switzerland sought to address this age-dependence. They first investigated the citation statistics of 450,000 papers from APS journals that were published between 1893 and 2009. They found that a paper’s relevance—defined by how many new citations it receives over a given period—decreases dramatically a few years after its publication. By introducing a decaying relevancy factor, the team produced a generic model that could fit a wide variety of network behavior, including the citation distribution of papers from APS journals. – Michael Schirber


Subject Areas

Nonlinear DynamicsComplex Systems

Related Articles

Controllable Topological Vortex Lattices
Complex Systems

Controllable Topological Vortex Lattices

Liquid crystals can be coaxed into hosting an easily reconfigurable lattice of vortices useful for information encoding. Read More »

How to Make Supply Chains More Resilient
Interdisciplinary Physics

How to Make Supply Chains More Resilient

When demand increases significantly, the better performing supply networks are those that allow for storage of excess materials and that contain multiple redundant pathways. Read More »

Internal Feedback Shapes Coral Reefs
Computational Physics

Internal Feedback Shapes Coral Reefs

A 1D model based on mineral accumulation and polyp mortality shows traveling pulses that drive atoll-like patterns. Read More »

More Articles