Synopsis: Nuclear Masses Don’t Add Up

The sum of the proton and deuteron masses minus the helium-3 nucleus mass, obtained from a measurement with a molecular ion, remains at odds with the number calculated from accepted values for these masses.

In 2015 Edmund Myers at Florida State University in Tallahassee and colleagues reported measurements of atomic mass ratios that left researchers puzzled. Their data implied that the sum of the masses of the proton and deuteron minus the mass of the helium-3 nucleus, that is, mp+mdmh, was much smaller—by more than 4 standard deviations—than the value deduced by combining accepted values of the individual masses. Something didn’t add up. Either the Myers team’s measurements or the individual mass values were off. A subsequent measurement of the proton mass was made by other researchers, implying that the accepted proton mass had indeed been too large (see 18 July 2017 Synopsis). However, the discrepancy remained at more than 3 standard deviations. Now, in a rerun of their experiment, Myers and co-workers confirm their 2015 result with improved precision.

For their experiments, the team used a Penning trap mass spectrometer. This setup can precisely measure the ratio of the cyclotron frequencies of two trapped ions, from which the ions’ mass ratio is inferred. Myers and colleagues significantly improved their 2015 apparatus, reducing both the inhomogeneity of the trap’s magnetic field and the noise in the apparatus detection circuit. They then redid their measurement of the ratio of the masses of 3He+ and the molecular ion HD+, which can be converted to mp+mdmh. Because of the reduced uncertainty, their result again differs by more than 4 standard deviations from the value calculated using the updated smaller proton mass and the masses of the deuteron and of the helium-3 nucleus. The finding may have implications for the proposed revision of the International System of Units (SI) in terms of fundamental constants.

This research is published in Physical Review A.

­–Ana Lopes

Ana Lopes is a Senior Editor of Physics.


More Features »


More Announcements »

Subject Areas

Atomic and Molecular Physics

Previous Synopsis

Biological Physics

A New Gauge for Age

Read More »

Related Articles

Synopsis: Making Mixtures of Magnetic Condensates
Atomic and Molecular Physics

Synopsis: Making Mixtures of Magnetic Condensates

A condensate mixing two species of strongly magnetic atoms provides a new experimental window into many-body phenomena. Read More »

Synopsis: Ion Suppresses Rydberg Creation
Atomic and Molecular Physics

Synopsis: Ion Suppresses Rydberg Creation

Forming an ion in an ultracold atomic cloud delays the subsequent creation of a Rydberg atom until the ion wanders away. Read More »

Viewpoint: Cold Atoms Bear a Quantum Scar
Quantum Information

Viewpoint: Cold Atoms Bear a Quantum Scar

Theorists attribute the unexpectedly slow thermalization of cold atoms seen in recent experiments to an effect called quantum many-body scarring. Read More »

More Articles