Synopsis: The Unbearable Hardness of Physics

Researchers have proved that extracting dynamical equations from data is in general a computationally hard problem.
Synopsis figure
T. S. Cubitt et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. (2012)

Physics students know from their late nights that working through the classic textbooks is hard. But can the anecdotal sense of “hardness” be given more rigorous foundation? More specifically, can the basic scientific problem of analyzing experimental data to ascertain the underlying equations be assessed for difficulty? In a paper in Physical Review Letters, Toby Cubitt at the Complutense University of Madrid, Spain, and colleagues have applied the tools used by computer science researchers to link notions of computational hardness to the difficulty of inferring dynamical equations from observational data.

Computer scientists classify computational hardness by how long it takes to solve a problem as a function of the size of the problem: cases in which the time is a polynomial function of size are in class P and are said to be “tractable” or “efficiently solvable” problems; problems for which the required time explodes exponentially with size are called NP-hard. The latter are something of a gold standard for computational complexity and can’t be solved efficiently.

Cubitt et al. prove theoretically that, regardless of experimental precision, deducing the dynamical equations that describe a system’s evolution is an NP-hard problem. The result applies to classical and quantum systems both, regardless of dynamical details. At the same time, the authors have also solved a 70-year-old puzzle in probability theory called the embedding problem, which relates to how a Markov process (i.e., one in which the system carries no memory) can be represented by transitions from state to state. Although the results may not comfort students burning the midnight oil, nor dissuade physicists from analyzing their data, the finding does have implications for generic automated inference machines that might boil data down to the underlying physics. – David Voss


Features

More Features »

Announcements

More Announcements »

Subject Areas

Interdisciplinary PhysicsComplex SystemsComputational Physics

Previous Synopsis

Quantum Information

Send in the Clones

Read More »

Next Synopsis

Nonlinear Dynamics

Telling Left From Right

Read More »

Related Articles

Focus: Astronomy Students Not Learning the Basics
Interdisciplinary Physics

Focus: Astronomy Students Not Learning the Basics

Nearly half of middle school students in a Norwegian study thought that planets are bigger than stars, even after astronomy instruction. Read More »

Synopsis: Social Determinants of Epidemic Growth
Complex Systems

Synopsis: Social Determinants of Epidemic Growth

A new network model reveals that social mixing and mobility can determine the areas of a city that are critical in provoking an epidemic outbreak. Read More »

Focus: Identifying Early Signs of Online Extremist Groups
Complex Systems

Focus: Identifying Early Signs of Online Extremist Groups

An analogy between the growth of online networks and the formation of gels suggests ways to detect extremist groups before they become influential. Read More »

More Articles