Synopsis: Greed is Good

A network model incorporates the way humans use a sense of orientation to make locally optimal decisions when they navigate city streets.

Many a tourist has, perhaps happily, gotten lost in the twists and turns along the way to Venice’s Piazza San Marco. How navigable a city is—or could be with an extra footbridge or better-placed signs—is something network models try to quantify. Now, writing in Physical Review Letters, two scientists show how one such model could better account for the way humans actually go about reaching a destination.

Sang Hoon Lee and Petter Holme at Umeå University in Sweden focus on a type of “greedy” navigation model, where at each point on a map, a navigator heads in the direction most in line with her destination (say a tall building in the distance) and only backtracks if she can’t move to a point that hasn’t already been visited. The model thus assumes a navigator has more information than one making random decisions, but doesn’t have at hand any “smart” technology telling her the overall shortest route.

Using maps of New York, Boston, and the Swiss Rail System, as well as the maze at Leeds Castle in England, the authors compare the distance traveled by a greedy navigator with that taken by a random navigator and the actual shortest path. Not surprisingly, greedy navigators get to where they are going in a much shorter distance than random travelers, though this advantage almost vanishes in the disorienting twists and turns in a maze.

Such models could be used to figure out the impact of blocking off certain bridges, tunnels, or roads on drivers or pedestrians trying to navigate a city. What do Lee and Holme advise to keep a greedy navigator’s trip as short as possible in Boston? Keep the Harvard Bridge open. – Jessica Thomas


Features

More Features »

Announcements

More Announcements »

Subject Areas

Nonlinear DynamicsInterdisciplinary Physics

Previous Synopsis

Next Synopsis

Optics

Nuclear Clocks

Read More »

Related Articles

Viewpoint: Language Boundaries Driven by Surface Tension
Interdisciplinary Physics

Viewpoint: Language Boundaries Driven by Surface Tension

A new model of language evolution assumes that changes in the spatial boundaries between dialects are controlled by a surface tension effect. Read More »

Focus: <i>Image</i>—Cooperating Lasers Make Topological Defects
Nonlinear Dynamics

Focus: Image—Cooperating Lasers Make Topological Defects

A circle of interacting lasers is a new model system for exploring topological defects, disordered structures that show up in a wide variety of seemingly unrelated systems. Read More »

Synopsis: Pinpointing Ebbs and Flows of Commuter Traffic
Interdisciplinary Physics

Synopsis: Pinpointing Ebbs and Flows of Commuter Traffic

Vulnerabilities in a city’s public transport system are identified through a network analysis that accounts for the number of passengers and vehicles at any given time. Read More »

More Articles