Synopsis: Ideal Mergers for Measuring Cosmic Expansion

Among gravitational-wave sources, the merger of a neutron star and a black hole may provide the most precise way to measure how fast the Universe is expanding.
Synopsis figure
A. Tonita, L. Rezzolla/Goethe University of Frankfurt​, &​ F. Pannarale/Sapienza University of Rome

Gravitational-wave astronomy is budding with possibilities, such as the use of gravitational-wave sources as distance markers for measuring cosmic expansion. A new report from Salvatore Vitale from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, and Hsin-Yu Chen from Harvard University shows that a specific kind of gravitational-wave source—involving the merger of a black hole with a neutron star—could be the best target for determining the expansion rate.

The current expansion rate, or Hubble constant, is a crucial factor in cosmological calculations, so its uncertainty limits how well we know other parameters, like the age of the Universe. But some measurements of the Hubble constant using the cosmic microwave background give different results than those based on supernova observations (see 20 April 2018 Feature), so researchers would like a third, independent method to resolve the tension.

Mergers of compact objects can be used to measure the Hubble constant. This is most easily done when the event is observed in two ways: with gravitational waves (to gauge the distance to the source) and with electromagnetic waves (to determine the source’s velocity). Such a Hubble constant measurement was already demonstrated with the observed merger of two neutron stars (see 16 October 2017 Viewpoint). But the uncertainty was fairly high (14%) because of uncertainty in the orbital orientation, which is correlated with the measured distance of the merger. Vitale and Chen show that neutron star black hole (NSBH) mergers give a more precise distance estimate than binary neutron star (BNS) mergers, mainly because the orbital orientation is less correlated with the distance measurement. No NSBH merger has yet been recorded. But if one NSBH event occurs for every 50 BNS events, which is consistent with current constraints, then future NSBH measurements will provide a more precise Hubble constant determination than BNS observations, according to Vitale and Chen.

This research is published in Physical Review Letters.

–Michael Schirber

Michael Schirber is a Corresponding Editor for Physics based in Lyon, France.


Features

More Features »

Announcements

More Announcements »

Subject Areas

CosmologyGravitation

Previous Synopsis

Next Synopsis

Computational Physics

Making Quantum Computations Behave

Read More »

Related Articles

Synopsis: Dark Matter Blowing Like a Hurricane  
Cosmology

Synopsis: Dark Matter Blowing Like a Hurricane  

The dark matter in our stellar neighborhood may be moving at high speed, which might produce a signature that future dark matter searches could detect.   Read More »

Viewpoint: Supernova Study Dampens Dark Matter Theory
Astrophysics

Viewpoint: Supernova Study Dampens Dark Matter Theory

A search for lensing of supernovae by black holes comes up empty, leading researchers to conclude that black holes cannot account for all dark matter. Read More »

Controversy Continues over Black Holes as Dark Matter
Astrophysics

Controversy Continues over Black Holes as Dark Matter

Following recent gravitational-wave detections, black holes have emerged as a possible, though contentious, dark matter candidate. Read More »

More Articles