Making Materials Mimic Each Other

    Alexey Gorlach1, Nicholas Rivera2, and Ido Kaminer1
    • 1Solid State Institute, Technion–Israel Institute of Technology, Haifa, Israel
    • 2Department of Physics, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA, USA
Physics 13, 75
A novel framework for controlling many-body systems with external fields shows how two distinct materials could be made to mimic each other or form more exotic materials.
Figure 1: With a newly proposed spectral mimicry scheme, researchers could make two different materials mimic each other’s spectra—or produce the spectrum of other, more exotic materials.

The puzzle of whether one can “hear the shape of a drum” [1] can be traced back to Hermann Weyl. The original question asks whether knowledge of the spectrum of a physical system uniquely determines its structure. An interesting twist on this question is whether one could make two time-dependent systems have the same properties by applying external “control fields” that also change with time. Now, Gerard McCaul, of Tulane University in Louisiana, and colleagues have proposed a new way to make one material behave like another by applying specially designed time-dependent fields such as laser pulses [2, 3]. The technique may let researchers manipulate the properties of different materials and study exotic materials that are otherwise hard to create.

Controlling how a quantum-mechanical system responds to time-dependent external fields, a technique called coherent control, is central to many areas of science and technology. For example, coherent control is used regularly in nuclear magnetic resonance experiments to prepare desired quantum states of qubits with radio-frequency pulses. Finding the ultimate limits to which tailoring the coherent control field can alter observables of a quantum system is therefore of great interest.

A natural question that follows is whether two distinct quantum systems can be made to have the same observable properties through coherent control. For example, can two atomic species, under the action of two different strong driving fields, be made to have the exact same spectrum of emitted light? This idea of spectral mimicry is appealing because it could potentially allow researchers to use readily available and well-understood materials to replicate the properties of exotic materials and thus reproduce phenomena that are usually hard to observe. Hopes in this direction include, for example, inducing superconductivity in new materials that usually do not have this property and creating photonic insulators—materials that block the transmission of light in one direction or another.

In 2017, researchers confirmed spectral mimicry to be theoretically possible by showing that two distinct atoms could have the same light emission spectrum under the proper choices of external, time-dependent electromagnetic fields [4]. This work had direct implications in the field of high harmonic generation (HHG), a highly nonlinear phenomenon in which a system driven by a strong electromagnetic field emits light with frequencies several times that of the driving field [5]. In this earlier work, each atom was described using a single-electron model. The puzzle intensifies in systems of many interacting electrons, such as solids. If coherent control can indeed be used to alter the system’s response, does it mean that insulators can be made to mimic conductors by application of the right control field?

McCaul et al. address this specific question, using it as an example of the principle that one many-electron system can act like another. They focus on the 1D Fermi-Hubbard model—a simplified model that describes a solid as a system of interacting fermions confined to sites on a lattice. The model has a (Mott) insulating phase and a conducting phase. Which phase the system is in depends on the ratio of its kinetic energy to its potential energy; the kinetic energy is associated with the electrons moving to different lattice sites, and the potential energy is associated with interactions between electrons. Typically, these two phases display different currents when exposed to external laser fields. And since the electric currents determine the emission of the system, the two phases would produce different spectra as well. But McCaul et al. found a way to apply suitable laser fields that would make the emission spectra of both phases identical, so that one system can “mimic” the behavior of another. Put another way, one can make two differently shaped drums sound identical under certain conditions.

This newly proposed mimicry scheme is based on an existing idea related to coherent control called tracking control [6]—a formula of sorts for finding what field is needed to make a system have some desired observable (for example, the expectation value of current in a solid). The tracking control method is attractive in being efficient and generic, applicable for closed as well as open systems. McCaul et al. formulate specific constraints with which the tracking control method guarantees the unique evolution of the system for any desirable expectation value.

The example considered in this work is an exciting proof of principle of what is possible in spectral mimicry in solid-state systems. But there are still questions to answer. For example, the researchers found that while it is possible for an insulator spectrum to mimic a conductor spectrum, the driving field forced the insulator to undergo a phase transition to a conducting state. It remains to be seen whether this spectral mimicry is possible without one of the systems making a phase transition into the phase of the other one. Even then, the researchers’ approach is still useful because it prescribes the field that’s needed to get the desired behavior. Another remaining question is whether this method of tracking control can be applied beyond the 1D Fermi-Hubbard toy model, looking instead at HHG in real solid-state systems—a topic of great current interest in the HHG community [7, 8].

Discoveries in coherent control are directly connected to a grander vision in the fundamentals of optics—to induce any desired optical response, both linear and nonlinear, in solid-state materials. One could envision the design of both a steady-state response and a transient response, allowing the creation of “out-of-equilibrium optical media.” An application of this idea is to apply new methods of coherent control to the recently reported phenomenon of light-induced superconductivity, where the optical response of a system could mimic that of a superconductor when exposed to a strong infrared optical field [9, 10].

Finally, it would be of great interest to consider coherent control with quantized driving fields, rather than classical driving fields, possibly allowing the use of coherent control to facilitate the generation of new quantum states of light [11]. With this in mind, future work could significantly extend the range of applications of tracking control and general coherent control methods into the area of quantum optics.

This research is published in Physical Review Letters and Physical Review A.


  1. M. Kac, “Can one hear the shape of a drum?” Am. Math. Mon. 73, 1 (1966).
  2. G. McCaul et al., “Driven imposters: Controlling expectations in many-body systems,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 124, 183201 (2020).
  3. G. McCaul et al., “Controlling arbitrary observables in correlated many-body systems,” Phys. Rev. A 101, 053408 (2020).
  4. A. G. Campos et al., “How to make distinct dynamical systems appear spectrally identical,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 118, 083201 (2017).
  5. P. B. Corkum, “Plasma perspective on strong field multiphoton ionization,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 71, 1994 (1993).
  6. W. Zhu and H. Rabitz, “Quantum control design via adaptive tracking,” J. Chem. Phys. 119, 3619 (2003).
  7. S. Ghimire et al., “Observation of high-order harmonic generation in a bulk crystal,” Nat. Phys. 7, 138 (2010).
  8. N. Tancogne-Dejean et al., “Impact of the electronic band structure in high-harmonic generation spectra of solids,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 118, 087403 (2017).
  9. D. Fausti et al., “Light-induced superconductivity in a stripe-ordered cuprate,” Science 331, 189 (2011).
  10. M. Mitrano et al., “Possible light-induced superconductivity in K3C60 at high temperature,” Nature 530, 461 (2016).
  11. A. Gorlach et al., “On the quantum-optical nature of high harmonic generation,” arXiv:1910.13791.

About the Authors

Image of Alexey Gorlach

Alexey Gorlach received an undergraduate degree in theoretical physics from Belarussian State University. He is now an M.Sc. student in nanotechnology and nanoscience at the Technion–Israel Institute of Technology. His research interests span a range of themes in quantum optics and quantum electrodynamics, including high harmonic generation and photon-induced nearfield electron microscopy.

Image of Nicholas Rivera

Nicholas Rivera is a graduate student in physics at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, where he also received his bachelor’s degree in physics. He is a recipient of a Department of Energy Computational Science Fellowship and the LeRoy Apker Award of the American Physical Society (APS). His research focuses on novel fundamental phenomena in the interactions of electrons with photons in nanophotonic systems, such as multiphoton processes, high harmonic generation, x-ray generation, and lasing interactions.

Image of Ido Kaminer

Ido Kaminer joined Technion–Israel Institute of Technology as an Assistant Professor after a postdoc at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, where he was a Rothschild Fellow and a Marie Curie Fellow. During his Ph.D., Ido discovered new classes of accelerating optical beams, for which he received the 2012 Israel Physical Society Prize and the 2014 APS Award for Outstanding Doctoral Dissertation in Laser Science. He is a recipient of the Azrieli Faculty Fellowship, GIF Young Scientists grant, and ERC starting grant. Ido’s research in quantum electrodynamics addresses fundamental and applied problems in photonics, plasmonics, 2D materials, and electron microscopy. His lab combines femtosecond lasers and electron microscopes, working toward novel light sources and ultrafast detectors.

Read PDF
Read PDF

Subject Areas


Related Articles

Boxes Go Topological for Sound
Condensed Matter Physics

Boxes Go Topological for Sound

In a chain of 3D printed boxes, only the first transmits sound waves with certain frequencies, evidence of a topological edge state.   Read More »

Controlling Particle Movements with Sound Waves

Controlling Particle Movements with Sound Waves

Using a carefully designed phononic device, researchers manipulate the motion of beads and cells along a surface. Read More »

Acoustic Diode Hits the Perfect Note

Acoustic Diode Hits the Perfect Note

A waveguide structure allows a specific type of sound wave to travel in only one direction with near-perfect transmission and without a power source required. Read More »

More Articles